Post
Analysis of the Pros and Cons of the Pokémon Trading Card Game Limited Battle EventA new limited battle event is causing a lot of controversy. This video provides a detailed analysis of the event's pros and cons, along with suggestions for future improvements. It focuses on the advantages for free-to-play users and the event's potential for expansion, while also addressing the current rules' monotony and the lack of communication from the developers.
1. 🤔 Limited Battle Event: Controversy and Video's Purpose
· Despite positive feedback on this season's packs and an 88% user approval rating in a poll during a stream, the new limited battle mode is causing controversy.
· This video will first address this controversy and then discuss the event's pros and cons, as well as future improvement directions.
· This video will first address this controversy and then discuss the event's pros and cons, as well as future improvement directions.
00:13 - 01:08
1. 🤔 Limited Battle Event: Controversy and Video's Purpose
· Despite positive feedback on this season's packs and an 88% user approval rating in a poll during a stream, the new limited battle mode is causing controversy.
· This video will first address this controversy and then discuss the event's pros and cons, as well as future improvement directions.
· This video will first address this controversy and then discuss the event's pros and cons, as well as future improvement directions.
01:15 - 04:01
2. 👍 Analyzing the Positive Aspects of the Limited Battle Event
· The first advantage is that the event is beneficial for free-to-play users. Packs can be collected without consuming separate resources, and unlike in the past, items like event hourglasses are not needed. Sand can be generated infinitely.
· While there are complaints about low drop rates, this is something that must be accepted to some extent. Additionally, for users who lack time, there are rewards offering 42 packs daily.
· A safety net through exchange tickets is also in place, so I believe it's balanced without missing anything.
· I don't really understand the reason for the controversy, as users who don't have time or care about drop rates have no reason to rush for Mewtwo Y.
· I believe the main reason the event is controversial is the lack of clear explanation. For example, it's difficult to know that you can get 3 packs per day without looking closely, so a lack of communication is partly to blame.
· If the number of packs obtainable daily had been clearly stated, many users would have been satisfied, so this was a missed opportunity.
· Past events had guaranteed drops including hourglasses, but currently, you get about 1 pack per hour, which can be quite stressful for users aiming solely to collect packs.
· While there are complaints about low drop rates, this is something that must be accepted to some extent. Additionally, for users who lack time, there are rewards offering 42 packs daily.
· A safety net through exchange tickets is also in place, so I believe it's balanced without missing anything.
· I don't really understand the reason for the controversy, as users who don't have time or care about drop rates have no reason to rush for Mewtwo Y.
· I believe the main reason the event is controversial is the lack of clear explanation. For example, it's difficult to know that you can get 3 packs per day without looking closely, so a lack of communication is partly to blame.
· If the number of packs obtainable daily had been clearly stated, many users would have been satisfied, so this was a missed opportunity.
· Past events had guaranteed drops including hourglasses, but currently, you get about 1 pack per hour, which can be quite stressful for users aiming solely to collect packs.
04:03 - 04:33
3. 🚀 Event's Expandability and Potential
· Although the explanation is somewhat lacking, the event system itself is quite generous.
· The second advantage is the high potential for event expansion. Looking at how the rules are written, it's expected that there will be seasons where elements like points are changed.
· This could lead to adjustments in deck size, and if a specific rule set is fun, it might even be applied to the main game. Therefore, it's something to look forward to.
· The second advantage is the high potential for event expansion. Looking at how the rules are written, it's expected that there will be seasons where elements like points are changed.
· This could lead to adjustments in deck size, and if a specific rule set is fun, it might even be applied to the main game. Therefore, it's something to look forward to.
04:34 - 05:07
4. ⏳ Event Pace and Lack of Variety
· However, a drawback is that the event is held too infrequently. Considering it's held about once every 1.5 months, the possibility of it becoming a mode that impacts the main game is low.
· Since promotional cards aren't strictly necessary, it would be good to rotate different rules every two weeks to broaden the variety of gameplay.
· Depending on the rules, it has the potential to become a masterpiece, so we'll have to watch future changes.
· Since promotional cards aren't strictly necessary, it would be good to rotate different rules every two weeks to broaden the variety of gameplay.
· Depending on the rules, it has the potential to become a masterpiece, so we'll have to watch future changes.
05:09 - 07:27
5. ❌ Problems with the Limited Battle Event: Monotony and Imbalance
· The biggest problem with the current rules is that they are extremely boring. Certain decks are too powerful, and there are almost no cards to turn the tables in unfavorable situations.
· Rabbit Jump allows for almost full offense, and the outcome is determined by a coin toss. Also, if you go first, Bronze can deal 130 damage from the second turn. Powerful decks like Mewtwo are also coin-toss decks.
· These powerful decks have a competitive power level in the current meta (Regulation C), but due to card restrictions, cards that resolve stalemates disappear. It's difficult to finish scoring easily without cards like Sabrina or Erika, and you end up losing by score difference in unfavorable situations.
· Furthermore, you can't keep up with fast decks like Bronze, which don't require Candy.
· Even with a Cog or Stadium, there's no way to remove them. Compared to the 'Genetic Apex' meta, you can't interfere with the board, and there are no counter-moves against these powerful cards, making them feel too strong.
· Bronze functions like Hydreigon, and there's no way to compete without Candy, Erika, or Sabrina in a matchup.
· Candy itself isn't the problem; the issue is that only Bronze monopolizes Candy, making it too powerful. This feels like an event where the game balance wasn't adjusted, only the cards were restricted.
· Even with excellent deck-building skills, it gives the impression that the range of usable decks has significantly narrowed.
· Rabbit Jump allows for almost full offense, and the outcome is determined by a coin toss. Also, if you go first, Bronze can deal 130 damage from the second turn. Powerful decks like Mewtwo are also coin-toss decks.
· These powerful decks have a competitive power level in the current meta (Regulation C), but due to card restrictions, cards that resolve stalemates disappear. It's difficult to finish scoring easily without cards like Sabrina or Erika, and you end up losing by score difference in unfavorable situations.
· Furthermore, you can't keep up with fast decks like Bronze, which don't require Candy.
· Even with a Cog or Stadium, there's no way to remove them. Compared to the 'Genetic Apex' meta, you can't interfere with the board, and there are no counter-moves against these powerful cards, making them feel too strong.
· Bronze functions like Hydreigon, and there's no way to compete without Candy, Erika, or Sabrina in a matchup.
· Candy itself isn't the problem; the issue is that only Bronze monopolizes Candy, making it too powerful. This feels like an event where the game balance wasn't adjusted, only the cards were restricted.
· Even with excellent deck-building skills, it gives the impression that the range of usable decks has significantly narrowed.
07:41 - 08:31
6. ⚖️ Balance Issues and Update Cycle: The Root of User Dissatisfaction
· The balance isn't great, but I don't think the imbalance itself is the problem. There's no ranked mode, normal matches are always available, and you have the option not to play the event.
· However, considering this is a new mode added with a shortened update cycle of two weeks, the quality was below expectations, and I believe this is the root cause of dissatisfaction.
· If it had been released with the usual update cycle, it would have served as a fresh change and received much positive feedback. But as a new mode to fill a two-week gap, the quality was too low.
· However, considering this is a new mode added with a shortened update cycle of two weeks, the quality was below expectations, and I believe this is the root cause of dissatisfaction.
· If it had been released with the usual update cycle, it would have served as a fresh change and received much positive feedback. But as a new mode to fill a two-week gap, the quality was too low.
08:32 - 10:26
7. 🗣️ Developers' Words vs. Actions: Deepening User Distrust
· The second problem is that the developers' actions don't align with their words.
· The developers explained the reason for slowing down the update speed as follows: They changed the cycle from the previous 4-week period to about 6 weeks starting with the new series because users felt it was difficult to collect cards, aiming to allow more users to enjoy collecting at their own pace. They also stated they would expand events and missions and update features to make the 6-week interval between expansion pack releases more enjoyable.
· However, if you apply card restriction rules just two weeks after a new set is released, free-to-play users will say, 'I haven't even collected all the cards yet!' This means events that further increase the barrier to entry should not be applied.
· Furthermore, while we expected rental decks to be provided for new users, I recall they weren't usable. The shiny version implemented this time was usable, which only widened the gap with paying users. I expect that in future cases like Mega Odium, only paying users will be able to use them.
· We have to accept the disappointing reason for slowing down the update speed. The previous update speed was somewhat frequent, and if it was for the benefit of free-to-play users, we could agree. But after half a month, this happening is too much.
· I believe this user distrust is reflected in the dissatisfaction with the current event.
· We can acknowledge that DeNA, being a mobile game company, may lack expertise in card games, and the balance of limited events being somewhat rough is understandable.
· However, I believe they should have some know-how in operating mobile game events.
· The developers explained the reason for slowing down the update speed as follows: They changed the cycle from the previous 4-week period to about 6 weeks starting with the new series because users felt it was difficult to collect cards, aiming to allow more users to enjoy collecting at their own pace. They also stated they would expand events and missions and update features to make the 6-week interval between expansion pack releases more enjoyable.
· However, if you apply card restriction rules just two weeks after a new set is released, free-to-play users will say, 'I haven't even collected all the cards yet!' This means events that further increase the barrier to entry should not be applied.
· Furthermore, while we expected rental decks to be provided for new users, I recall they weren't usable. The shiny version implemented this time was usable, which only widened the gap with paying users. I expect that in future cases like Mega Odium, only paying users will be able to use them.
· We have to accept the disappointing reason for slowing down the update speed. The previous update speed was somewhat frequent, and if it was for the benefit of free-to-play users, we could agree. But after half a month, this happening is too much.
· I believe this user distrust is reflected in the dissatisfaction with the current event.
· We can acknowledge that DeNA, being a mobile game company, may lack expertise in card games, and the balance of limited events being somewhat rough is understandable.
· However, I believe they should have some know-how in operating mobile game events.
10:32 - 10:48
8. 🛠️ Suspicions of Insufficient Playtesting and Deck Building Difficulties
· It's hard to understand the new card restriction rules where you can't collect the necessary cards, and the fact that shiny versions are available.
· Cards you can't choose keep appearing, making deck building cumbersome and raising doubts about whether playtesting was done properly.
· Cards you can't choose keep appearing, making deck building cumbersome and raising doubts about whether playtesting was done properly.
10:51 - 11:06
9. 😥 User Attrition Due to the Event and the Need for Improvement
· There was a tweet saying someone quit 'PokéPoké' because of this event, which is unfortunate given the effort to slow down to add new modes.
· I think more effort should have been put in.
· I think more effort should have been put in.
11:08 - 11:48
10. 💡 Improvement Suggestion 1: Making Limited Rules Permanent and Diversifying Them
· We can't just complain, so I want to offer suggestions for improvement.
· Since the rules seem flexible, these limited rules should be available almost all the time.
· It's okay even without promotional packs or rewards. If the rules are rotated and consistently maintained, they can be very fun independently of release periods or ranked seasons.
· If you discover a rule set that is very fun, it can greatly contribute to game growth.
· For example, Hearthstone's 'Battlegrounds' mode became very popular. I've heard of similar cases in Magic: The Gathering, so this is a realistic goal with great potential.
· Since the rules seem flexible, these limited rules should be available almost all the time.
· It's okay even without promotional packs or rewards. If the rules are rotated and consistently maintained, they can be very fun independently of release periods or ranked seasons.
· If you discover a rule set that is very fun, it can greatly contribute to game growth.
· For example, Hearthstone's 'Battlegrounds' mode became very popular. I've heard of similar cases in Magic: The Gathering, so this is a realistic goal with great potential.
11:58 - 12:32
11. 🤝 Improvement Suggestion 2: Introducing Rental Decks for New Users
· Second, rental decks should be introduced for the limited rules so that new users can also participate.
· As explained earlier, new users cannot collect cards quickly, which is why the update speed was slowed down.
· Adding modes that cannot be participated in is meaningless, so I believe rental decks for new users are essential.
· Completely new users who cannot participate in the event will feel alienated, so it's good to provide a fair competitive environment to encourage them to stay in the game.
· As explained earlier, new users cannot collect cards quickly, which is why the update speed was slowed down.
· Adding modes that cannot be participated in is meaningless, so I believe rental decks for new users are essential.
· Completely new users who cannot participate in the event will feel alienated, so it's good to provide a fair competitive environment to encourage them to stay in the game.
12:33 - 13:07
12. 🔧 Improvement Suggestion 3: Minor Balance Adjustments
· Third, although I don't have high expectations, I hope for some light balance adjustments.
· The balance of the limited rules feels quite neglected during the 1.5-month preparation period.
· Including cards like Natsume, or perhaps 'Ultimate Gene' might not be as problematic as board control cards. Also, Kiseki is too powerful, so cards like Blower or Guzma might be needed.
· Even minor adjustments would be sufficient, so I hope for improvements.
· The balance of the limited rules feels quite neglected during the 1.5-month preparation period.
· Including cards like Natsume, or perhaps 'Ultimate Gene' might not be as problematic as board control cards. Also, Kiseki is too powerful, so cards like Blower or Guzma might be needed.
· Even minor adjustments would be sufficient, so I hope for improvements.
13:08 - 13:54
13. 🎁 Improvement Suggestion 4: Motivation for Continuous Play
· Fourth, although not essential, it would be nice to have some motivation to keep playing.
· Promotional packs feel like a forced collection chore, giving the feeling of needing to complete a set but not wanting to play.
· If chase cards or even low-probability regular pack drops were added, the sense of obligation would decrease.
· Again, this is not essential.
· Unlike other elements of PokéPoké, this feels like a forced chore, so I believe it's an area that needs improvement.
· Promotional packs feel like a forced collection chore, giving the feeling of needing to complete a set but not wanting to play.
· If chase cards or even low-probability regular pack drops were added, the sense of obligation would decrease.
· Again, this is not essential.
· Unlike other elements of PokéPoké, this feels like a forced chore, so I believe it's an area that needs improvement.
13:56 - 14:21
14. 🌟 Event's Potential and Disappointments
· For now, this is how I feel about this event.
· Although the system is somewhat lacking, I believe it has very high potential to become an amazing event, so I look forward to future changes.
· This event feels like the request for limited rules was simply accepted and implemented irresponsibly, and linking it with promotional cards left a bad impression.
· Although the system is somewhat lacking, I believe it has very high potential to become an amazing event, so I look forward to future changes.
· This event feels like the request for limited rules was simply accepted and implemented irresponsibly, and linking it with promotional cards left a bad impression.
14:22 - 14:42
15. 💬 Gathering Viewer Opinions and Conclusion
· I think it's a somewhat divisive event, and I look forward to the next one. Thank you for watching.
· I'd also like to hear your opinions, so please leave them in the comments. If you found the video helpful or enjoyable, please subscribe and like the channel. See you in the next video. Goodbye.
· I'd also like to hear your opinions, so please leave them in the comments. If you found the video helpful or enjoyable, please subscribe and like the channel. See you in the next video. Goodbye.
