Post
Monster Hunter Now: "Carnibala 26" Gunlance, Comparison Analysis with Existing BuildsThis is an in-depth analysis video of Monster Hunter Now's new Gunlance, "Carniva 26". It compares the Focus build and firepower-focused build with existing weapons, detailing the pros and cons of each build and their actual combat efficiency.
1. 🎯 Focus Build Comparison: Carniva vs. Gragri
· Compares the skill composition and estimated firepower of the existing Gragri build and the new Carniva build for the Focus build comparison.
· The Gragri build has Focus 5, Artillery 5, Guard Performance 3, and an estimated shelling value of 3031.
· The Carniva build achieves Focus 5, Artillery 5, Guard Performance 5, and even Adrenaline 5, with an estimated shelling value of 2937.
· In terms of reflected damage, the Carniva build is slightly lower at approximately 2213 compared to the Gragri build (approximately 2308), but this can vary depending on the situation in actual combat.
· Guard Performance 5 reduces chip damage and enables guard reloads for specific attacks (like Crodia's charge, Diablos' dive, etc.), enhancing operational convenience.
· Overall, while Gragri has a slight edge in attack power, the Carniva build is considered marginally superior when considering Guard Performance.
· The Gragri build has Focus 5, Artillery 5, Guard Performance 3, and an estimated shelling value of 3031.
· The Carniva build achieves Focus 5, Artillery 5, Guard Performance 5, and even Adrenaline 5, with an estimated shelling value of 2937.
· In terms of reflected damage, the Carniva build is slightly lower at approximately 2213 compared to the Gragri build (approximately 2308), but this can vary depending on the situation in actual combat.
· Guard Performance 5 reduces chip damage and enables guard reloads for specific attacks (like Crodia's charge, Diablos' dive, etc.), enhancing operational convenience.
· Overall, while Gragri has a slight edge in attack power, the Carniva build is considered marginally superior when considering Guard Performance.
| Category | Gragri (Focus) | Carniva (Focus) |
|---|---|---|
| Estimated Shelling Value | 3031 | 2937 |
| Estimated Reflected Damage | Approx. 2308 | Approx. 2213 |
| Guard Performance | Lv 3 | Lv 5 |
00:16 - 01:26
1. 🎯 Focus Build Comparison: Carniva vs. Gragri
· Compares the skill composition and estimated firepower of the existing Gragri build and the new Carniva build for the Focus build comparison.
· The Gragri build has Focus 5, Artillery 5, Guard Performance 3, and an estimated shelling value of 3031.
· The Carniva build achieves Focus 5, Artillery 5, Guard Performance 5, and even Adrenaline 5, with an estimated shelling value of 2937.
· In terms of reflected damage, the Carniva build is slightly lower at approximately 2213 compared to the Gragri build (approximately 2308), but this can vary depending on the situation in actual combat.
· Guard Performance 5 reduces chip damage and enables guard reloads for specific attacks (like Crodia's charge, Diablos' dive, etc.), enhancing operational convenience.
· Overall, while Gragri has a slight edge in attack power, the Carniva build is considered marginally superior when considering Guard Performance.
· The Gragri build has Focus 5, Artillery 5, Guard Performance 3, and an estimated shelling value of 3031.
· The Carniva build achieves Focus 5, Artillery 5, Guard Performance 5, and even Adrenaline 5, with an estimated shelling value of 2937.
· In terms of reflected damage, the Carniva build is slightly lower at approximately 2213 compared to the Gragri build (approximately 2308), but this can vary depending on the situation in actual combat.
· Guard Performance 5 reduces chip damage and enables guard reloads for specific attacks (like Crodia's charge, Diablos' dive, etc.), enhancing operational convenience.
· Overall, while Gragri has a slight edge in attack power, the Carniva build is considered marginally superior when considering Guard Performance.
| Category | Gragri (Focus) | Carniva (Focus) |
|---|---|---|
| Estimated Shelling Value | 3031 | 2937 |
| Estimated Reflected Damage | Approx. 2308 | Approx. 2213 |
| Guard Performance | Lv 3 | Lv 5 |
03:15 - 05:44
2. 💥 Firepower Focus Build Comparison: Carniva vs. Indomitable Gragri
· Compares builds that forgo Focus skills to concentrate on firepower, specifically focusing on whether similar performance can be achieved without the 'Indomitable' skill's limitations.
· The Indomitable Gragri build records an estimated shelling value of 3541, which is higher than the Focus build.
· The Carniva Gunlance build has an estimated shelling value of 3333, about 5.9% lower than Indomitable Gragri, but its counter damage using Guard skills is higher at approximately 3308 compared to Indomitable Gragri (approximately 3131).
· While Indomitable Gragri has superior overall firepower, the Carniva build, which can be operated without the 'Indomitable' skill's restrictions, is also quite competitive.
· Actual 10-star solo time attack records show that the Focus build has reached its limit, while the Indomitable build shows better performance. This suggests that the efficiency of the Focus build has decreased in the current meta.
· Therefore, unless there's a specific reason, a firepower-focused build is recommended over a Focus build.
· The Indomitable Gragri build records an estimated shelling value of 3541, which is higher than the Focus build.
· The Carniva Gunlance build has an estimated shelling value of 3333, about 5.9% lower than Indomitable Gragri, but its counter damage using Guard skills is higher at approximately 3308 compared to Indomitable Gragri (approximately 3131).
· While Indomitable Gragri has superior overall firepower, the Carniva build, which can be operated without the 'Indomitable' skill's restrictions, is also quite competitive.
· Actual 10-star solo time attack records show that the Focus build has reached its limit, while the Indomitable build shows better performance. This suggests that the efficiency of the Focus build has decreased in the current meta.
· Therefore, unless there's a specific reason, a firepower-focused build is recommended over a Focus build.
| Category | Indomitable Gragri | Carniva (Firepower Focus) |
|---|---|---|
| Estimated Shelling Value | 3541 | 3333 |
| Estimated Counter Damage | Approx. 3131 | Approx. 3308 |
| Features | Max firepower, requires 'Indomitable' | High versatility, no 'Indomitable' requirement |
06:05 - 08:36
3. ⚔️ Poke-Shell & Counter Build: Carniva vs. Bazel Buster
· Compares the performance of the Carniva Gunlance and Bazel Buster in a poke-shell style.
· Bazel Buster is a Wide type with high shelling damage but requires a skill-focused build. Estimated poke value is 3528, shelling value is 3133.
· Carniva Gunlance is a Long type with a longer range and significantly higher poke damage of approximately 4367. However, its shelling damage is lower at approximately 2027.
· Carniva has superior Guard Performance at 5, and considering explosive damage, Bazel Buster might be marginally superior.
· In actual combat, Bazel Buster showed slightly faster clear times including explosive damage, but this is a calculated value and can vary depending on the monster's status effect resistance.
· In conclusion, if you already have a completed Bazel build, the priority for upgrading to a Carniva build is low. However, if you are starting a new counter build, Carniva can be a good option.
· Bazel Buster is a Wide type with high shelling damage but requires a skill-focused build. Estimated poke value is 3528, shelling value is 3133.
· Carniva Gunlance is a Long type with a longer range and significantly higher poke damage of approximately 4367. However, its shelling damage is lower at approximately 2027.
· Carniva has superior Guard Performance at 5, and considering explosive damage, Bazel Buster might be marginally superior.
· In actual combat, Bazel Buster showed slightly faster clear times including explosive damage, but this is a calculated value and can vary depending on the monster's status effect resistance.
· In conclusion, if you already have a completed Bazel build, the priority for upgrading to a Carniva build is low. However, if you are starting a new counter build, Carniva can be a good option.
| Category | Bazel Buster (Poke-Shell) | Carniva (Poke-Shell) |
|---|---|---|
| Estimated Poke Value | 3528 | 4367 |
| Estimated Shelling Value | 3133 | 2027 |
| Guard Performance | Lv 3 | Lv 5 |
| Additional Damage | Explosive Damage | - |
09:09 - 10:49
4. 📈 Overall Conclusion and Recommended Builds by Playstyle
· Summarizes the analysis from sections 1-3 to present recommended builds for each playstyle.
· Shelling Build: If you have a completed Gragri build, the priority for upgrading to a Carniva build is low. However, Carniva is recommended if you are starting fresh.
· Explosive Build: If you have a completed Bazel build, the priority for a Carniva build is low, especially if you are not a Gunner. Carniva could be considered for Gunner users.
· Carniva Gunlance offers an option to improve operational convenience, such as Guard Performance, at a similar damage level, rather than overwhelmingly superior performance compared to existing weapons.
· It is recommended to take advantage of the Season 11 final event period and use Mysterious Stones to reduce the burden of farming materials.
· Shelling Build: If you have a completed Gragri build, the priority for upgrading to a Carniva build is low. However, Carniva is recommended if you are starting fresh.
· Explosive Build: If you have a completed Bazel build, the priority for a Carniva build is low, especially if you are not a Gunner. Carniva could be considered for Gunner users.
· Carniva Gunlance offers an option to improve operational convenience, such as Guard Performance, at a similar damage level, rather than overwhelmingly superior performance compared to existing weapons.
· It is recommended to take advantage of the Season 11 final event period and use Mysterious Stones to reduce the burden of farming materials.
