Post
FGO: AoE vs. Single-Target NP, which format is better? In-depth analysis!
This video provides an in-depth analysis of whether single-target or AoE (Area of Effect) Noble Phantasms are more advantageous in the FGO Grand Battle, comparing the pros and cons of each type and offering opinions on future directions. In particular, it points out the problems with the Indra format and suggests improvements.
1. ⚔️ Grand Battle Format Debate: Single vs. AoE, What's the Problem?
- ✅ Discussions are ongoing about which format, single-target or AoE Noble Phantasm, is more advantageous through the three Grand Battles held so far.
- ⚠️ In the past, the single-target Noble Phantasm format was advantageous, but the Indra format, which requires both single-target and AoE, has created new problems.
- 🤔 It is necessary to analyze the pros and cons of each format and seek improvement directions to determine which format will be better in the future.
00:00 - 00:34
1. ⚔️ Grand Battle Format Debate: Single vs. AoE, What's the Problem?
- ✅ Discussions are ongoing about which format, single-target or AoE Noble Phantasm, is more advantageous through the three Grand Battles held so far.
- ⚠️ In the past, the single-target Noble Phantasm format was advantageous, but the Indra format, which requires both single-target and AoE, has created new problems.
- 🤔 It is necessary to analyze the pros and cons of each format and seek improvement directions to determine which format will be better in the future.
00:35 - 01:49
2. 🎯 Advantages and Limitations of Single-Target Noble Phantasm Priority Quests
- ✅ In single-target Noble Phantasm quests, single-target Noble Phantasm Servants are more likely to exert powerful firepower.
- ✅ AoE Noble Phantasm Servants can also be used depending on card luck through Oda Nobunaga & Chen strategies.
- ⚠️ If the enemy is single, various Servants can be used regardless of the Noble Phantasm type.
01:50 - 02:30
3. 💥 Problems with AoE Noble Phantasm Priority Quests
- ⚠️ In AoE Noble Phantasm quests, it becomes difficult to utilize single-target Noble Phantasm Servants.
- ⚠️ Even if Oda Nobunaga & Chen are used, clearing may be difficult depending on card luck.
- ⚠️ AoE Noble Phantasm quests can be cleared with card attacks because the enemy's HP is low, but this is difficult with the damage from single-target Noble Phantasm Servants.
02:31 - 03:35
4. 🤝 Indra Format Dilemma: The Importance of Teamwork
- ⚠️ The Indra format requires both AoE and single-target Noble Phantasms, but it is difficult to clear with only one.
- 🤝 Teamwork, which requires using both your own and your friend's Servants, becomes important.
- 🤔 The Indra format seems to be set up without leaning towards either single-target or AoE, but in reality, it is a format that gives difficulties to both sides.
03:36 - 04:28
5. ⚖️ Complete Equality is Impossible: Is the Indra Format the Best?
- ⚖️ Regardless of which format is selected, Servants of a specific Noble Phantasm type will experience difficulties.
- 🤔 It is suggested that the Indra format gives difficulties to each other, but paradoxically, it may be the most balanced format.
04:29 - 05:46
6. 🗣️ User Opinions: Preference for Single-Target Noble Phantasm Priority
- 🗣️ Many users tend to prefer the single-target Noble Phantasm priority format over the Indra format.
- ⚠️ There is an opinion that the Indra format is inconvenient because it requires using Noble Phantasms twice and relies heavily on friend Servants.
- 🤝 There are many cases where difficulties are experienced because the composition of friend Servants (Noble Phantasm type, Craft Essence, etc.) does not match.
05:47 - 06:37
7. 🎯 Reconfirmation of the Advantages of Single-Target Noble Phantasm Quests
- 🎯 Single-target Noble Phantasm quests are preferred because AoE/support Servants can also be utilized, and reliance on friend Servants can be reduced.
- ✅ It is analyzed that single-target Noble Phantasm quests provide opportunities for more Servants and can lower the difficulty of clearing.
06:38 - 07:16
8. 🤔 Future Direction: The Importance of Gathering User Opinions
- 🤔 It is important to gather various opinions because the preferred quest format may differ depending on the Servant possession status of users.
- 🤝 Personally, the Indra format is easy to manage friend Servants, but this may differ from general opinions.
- 🗣️ A request is made to present opinions on which quest format users prefer and in which direction they should proceed in the future.
07:17 - 08:36
9. 🔮 The 'True' AoE Noble Phantasm Priority Quest That Hasn't Come Yet
- 🔮 The 'true' AoE Noble Phantasm priority quest has not yet appeared, and attention is paid to the possibility of it appearing in the future.
- ⚔️ For example, it is predicted that a situation may arise where an Assassin class with a bankruptcy legion appears, making AoE Noble Phantasm Assassins advantageous.
- ⚠️ Like the Indra format, it may be in the form of a boss monster with high HP, and damage can only be dealt to the boss by defeating the surrounding monsters.
- 😨 There are concerns about the possibility of quests appearing where the HP of the entire enemy is very high and can only be cleared with AoE Noble Phantasms.
08:37 - 10:13
10. 💡 New Quest Gimmick Proposal: Monster Strike Method
- 💡 An idea is presented to introduce gimmicks frequently used in Monster Strike into FGO.
- 🤝 A method of sharing the HP of the boss monster and surrounding monsters, or reducing the HP of the boss monster when surrounding monsters are defeated.
- 💥 Through this, it is possible to configure quests that can be used advantageously for both AoE and single-target Noble Phantasms.
- 🙏 It is hoped that quests that can satisfy users will be created by adopting these gimmicks.
10:14 - 11:05
11. ✨ Ideal Quest Form: In a Direction That Satisfies Everyone
- ✨ The most ideal thing is to provide separate quests for AoE Noble Phantasms and single-target Noble Phantasms, but this is expected to be difficult in reality.
- 💡 A realistic alternative is to improve the Indra format to create quests optimized for both AoE and single-target.
- 🔮 The video ends by expressing anticipation for future quests.