Post
Analysis of Denial Regarding the Ashes of Creation Scam
The video analyzes the denial of some members of the community about the Ashes of Creation scam, focusing on an individual named Zyac who defends the game's creator despite the evidence. The justifications given by Zyac are discussed and contrasted with the reality of the situation, including the creator's financial history and the actions taken before the game's closure.
1. 🎮 Introduction to the Denial of the Ashes of Creation Scam and Presentation of Zyac
- ✅ The video introduces the topic of denial about the Ashes of Creation scam.
- ✅ Zyac, an individual who defends the game and its creator, is introduced, even after the scam was confirmed.
- ⚠️ Zyac believes that negative opinions should be ignored.
00:00 - 01:27
1. 🎮 Introduction to the Denial of the Ashes of Creation Scam and Presentation of Zyac
- ✅ The video introduces the topic of denial about the Ashes of Creation scam.
- ✅ Zyac, an individual who defends the game and its creator, is introduced, even after the scam was confirmed.
- ⚠️ Zyac believes that negative opinions should be ignored.
01:28 - 02:07
2. 🎮 Unjustified Defense of the Creator of Ashes of Creation by Zyac
- ✅ Zyac defends Stephen Sharief, the creator of Ashes of Creation, even though the latter ran off with the money.
- ⚠️ Zyac believes that Stephen wanted to make a good MMORPG and had no dubious intentions.
02:08 - 03:49
3. 🎮 Refutation of Zyac's Arguments and Emphasis on the Reality of the Scam
- ✅ Zyac's refusal to accept the reality of the scam is criticized.
- ⚠️ It is pointed out that Stephen Sharief obtained his wealth from multi-level marketing schemes, which contradicts the idea that he never had bad intentions.
- ✅ Zyac's argument that it didn't make sense for it to be a scam from the beginning is refuted, asking why not run away with more money later.
03:50 - 05:41
4. 🎮 Criticism of the Ashes of Creation Community and the Irrational Defense of the Game
- ✅ The Ashes of Creation community is criticized for defending the game irrationally.
- ⚠️ The contradiction that someone who benefited from a multi-level scheme would not scam anyone is highlighted.
- ✅ It is argued that Zyac's statements should be enough to convince anyone that he is wrong.
05:42 - 07:09
5. 🎮 Analysis of Zyac's Justifications and the Creator's Desperation
- ✅ It is questioned why Stephen Sharief would hire so many people and put in so much effort if he was just going to scam people.
- ⚠️ It is suggested that Stephen became over-indebted and started making deals with the devil, which led to the current situation.
- ✅ The idea that Stephen's bad decisions are not his fault is criticized.
07:10 - 08:40
6. 🎮 Comparison with Pirate Software and the Persistence of Zyac's Denial
- ✅ The situation is compared to Pirate Software, who at least tried to use the situation to paint himself in a good light.
- ⚠️ It is highlighted that Zyac is still denying reality and probably believes that the game can return.
- ✅ The simplification of the situation by Zyac is criticized, who does not recognize the obvious reason why Stephen launched the game on Steam.
08:41 - 11:24
7. 🎮 Final Reflections on the Scam and Persistent Denial
- ✅ It is reiterated that the situation is simple and that Stephen was not an evil supervillain, but wanted to make a great game.
- ⚠️ The claim that the game was close to being finished is criticized, pointing out that most of the game's elements were not complete.
- ✅ It is highlighted that the promises made were not fulfilled.
11:25 - 17:45
8. 🎮 Financial Analysis and the Possibility of Loans for Stephen Sharief
- ✅ It is discussed whether Stephen Sharief financed 30 million from his own pocket and whether the costs of one million a month to maintain Ashes of Creation are possible.
- ⚠️ It is explained how financial leverage works and how Stephen could have obtained loans using his assets as collateral.
- ✅ It is questioned whether Stephen is well-known enough to obtain this type of loan.
- ✅ A story is shared about someone who defrauded a bank and then obtained a larger loan from the same bank.
- ⚠️ It is suggested that Stephen may have had a "in for a penny, in for a pound" mentality and that he has a gambler's fallacy.
- ✅ It is mentioned that Zyac sent Stephen a direct message telling him that he believes in him, and Stephen replied that Zyac is one of the good ones.