Post

Reasons for Conan's low popularity overseas? Honest fan reactions analyzedWhy isn't 'Detective Conan,' which enjoys immense popularity in Japan, gaining significant traction overseas? This analysis explores the reasons through various fan reactions, offering insights into the series' charm and the perspectives of international fans.
Reasons for Conan's low popularity overseas? Honest fan reactions analyzed
1. 🤔 Overseas Fans Discuss the Reasons for Conan's Lower Popularity
· Fans express surprise and questions about Conan's lower-than-expected popularity outside Japan.
· While the dubbing quality was good, the broadcast times overlapped with children's anime like Dragon Ball and One Piece, making it difficult to capture a young audience.
· Analysis suggests that while adults can enjoy Conan as a mystery series, its accessibility was limited during childhood.
00:00 - 00:32
1. 🤔 Overseas Fans Discuss the Reasons for Conan's Lower Popularity
· Fans express surprise and questions about Conan's lower-than-expected popularity outside Japan.
· While the dubbing quality was good, the broadcast times overlapped with children's anime like Dragon Ball and One Piece, making it difficult to capture a young audience.
· Analysis suggests that while adults can enjoy Conan as a mystery series, its accessibility was limited during childhood.
00:48 - 01:22
2. 🇺🇸 US Market Specifics and Conan's Pacing
· In the US, anime is typically broadcast in 52-episode arcs. However, Conan's early episodes, before the introduction of key character Ai Haibara, didn't meet this volume, leading to a perceived slow start.
· Some fans enjoyed the pattern of Conan and his friends solving murders, while others gave up because the story never seemed to end.
· The lack of character development despite technological advancements and the absence of 'pleasant murder cases,' Conan's core appeal, were mentioned as drawbacks.
01:23 - 02:04
3. 🌍 Broadcast Environments by Country and Conan's Violence Controversy
· Experiences were shared about Conan being broadcast late at night in some countries due to violence, making it difficult to watch.
· Some regretted prioritizing other anime like One Piece over Conan's broadcast schedule.
· Criticisms included 'too violent for children and too childish for adults,' along with sympathy for young viewers who struggled to watch Conan late at night.
· Agreement that Conan might be considered somewhat violent by US standards, contrasted with its unrestricted broadcast in Germany.
02:07 - 02:59
4. 🗣️ Overseas Fans' Diverse Views on Conan's 'Darkness'
· The famous line 'The truth is always one' was noted as sounding somewhat awkward when translated directly as 'The truth is always one' in English.
· Regarding the opinion that Conan is dark, some recalled not feeling that way when reading the manga as children, while acknowledging it might be perceived as dark by US standards.
· While Germany could broadcast bloody scenes without issue, the assessment of Conan being dark might be accurate for the US.
· Experiences were shared where Conan was deemed unsuitable for children in some countries due to its violence.
· Criticisms included 'too violent for children and too childish for adults,' along with sympathy for young viewers who struggled to watch Conan late at night.
· Amusement at the phrase 'pleasant murder cases' was expressed, alongside shared traumatic experiences with Conan's violent scenes.
03:06 - 03:55
5. 🎶 Nostalgic Openings and Popular Anime of the Era
· Nostalgic mentions of Detective Conan's early opening and ending themes.
· Recollections of the era when Conan aired alongside other popular anime like 'If You Do It, You Do It' and 'The Fairy and the Magician.'
· Expressions of longing for the time when 'If You Do It, You Do It' and 'The Fairy and the Magician' were broadcast.
04:03 - 04:34
6. ⏳ Conan's Never-Ending Story and Popularity Factors
· Predictions that Conan will not end easily due to the slow pacing of the original manga.
· Mention that the author, Gosho Aoyama, seems strongly committed to continuing the serialization.
· The ongoing release of related episodes and gradual disclosure of information suggest the series could continue for another 50 years.
· Analysis indicates no strong push towards a conclusion, with the author seemingly favoring characters like Kaito Kid and Shuichi Akai.
· Episodes focusing on romantic subplots for Kogoro Mouri and Ai Haibara are also seen as devices to prolong the story.
04:36 - 05:30
7. 🤔 Impact of Japanese Culture and Language Barriers on Conan's Overseas Popularity
· Pointed out that tricks and cases relying on Japanese grammar, culture, or geography might be difficult for foreign viewers to understand.
· Emphasized Conan's unique popularity in Japan, noting that even many Japanese people don't read many translated mystery novels.
· Questioned the reasons behind Japanese people's love for mystery stories and Conan's popularity even among elementary school students.
· Analysis suggests early Conan excelled at captivating children, and Japan has a cultural background relatively lenient towards violent depictions in media.
· Explained the experience of watching 2-hour mystery dramas, the impact of reruns, and how Conan expanded its popularity to elementary students after success in shonen manga magazines.
· Proposed that the current immense popularity is largely influenced by female fans.
05:50 - 07:23
8. 🌍 Overseas Fans' Interpretations and Cultural Differences
· Curiosity about whether characters like 'Toru Amuro' will maintain their popularity overseas.
· Shared an experience of hearing about Conan from a Chinese friend met in the US, noting Conan's significant popularity in China.
· While expecting Americans or British people to prefer Sherlock Holmes, it was revealed that ardent Sherlockians in the UK intensely dislike Conan.
· Specifically explained that the 'The Case of the Holmes Freak Murder' episode drew backlash from Sherlockians.
· Pointed out that many depictions in Conan seem to mock Sherlockians, and the killer's motive being a Sherlockian is difficult for overseas fans to comprehend.
07:34 - 08:14
9. 🕵️ Sherlockians' Outrage: Controversy Over Conan's Holmes-Related Episodes
· Detailed how overseas Sherlockians were angered by the 'The Case of the Holmes Freak Murder' episode, which contained numerous depictions seemingly mocking Sherlock Holmes fans.
· Explained that the killer's motive was related to worshipping Irene Adler, a character from the Holmes stories.
· Analyzed that the premise of a fan club member committing murders out of rage over a fanfic writer prioritizing Irene, the main heroine, was perceived as an extreme and incomprehensible act by overseas fans.
· Emphasized the intense anger from Sherlockians who felt such actions were being justified under the guise of 'love' for Holmes and Irene.
명탐정코난코난해외반응애니메이션추리물